Mobility-as-a-Service, the future of Mobility?

18

October

2019

No ratings yet.

Recently, a pilot with shared electric vehicles has started in Rotterdam. The small, electric vehicles of Lev offer a new, comfortable, way of transport to move through the city (Rotterdam, 2019). Next to the possibility of driving this car, it is also possible to take a Felyx (shared scooter), or a bike (Mobike). However, these different providers of transport all have their own app, which needs to be installed before consumers can utilize their services. A concept which combines all these different transport modes into one interface is called Mobility-as-a-Service (MaaS). Is this concept going to be the future of mobility?

MaaS offers several advantages. Firstly, it decreases the need for owning private vehicles, by ensuring that a consumer can take its preferred mode of transport mode at any time (Gould, 2015). Because of this, MaaS can also contribute to the sustainability vision, since it can reduce the negative effects of the use of private cars on urban contexts and environment (Giesecke, Surakka, & Hakonen, 2016). Besides, MaaS can contribute to increasing access in reaching places and increase the ability to make use of different transport modes (König, Eckhardt, Aapaoja, Sochor, & Karlsson, 2016). These advantages could cause that MaaS is going to be a widely accepted concept in the future.

However, there are also a few reasons why MaaS might not be the future of mobility. Although MaaS would be a very convenient platform for users, companies might not be that eager to join such a platform. Most companies already have their own channel to offer their mobility options. Think of Uber and Felyx, which both have their own app. If rides are going to be booked via a MaaS platform, Uber and Felyx might have to pay a fee to this platform. So, costs might rise while returns will be the same. Besides, firms also lose direct contact with their customers and are dependent on the customer service of a third-party.

So, is MaaS going to be the future of mobility? If it was up to customers, I would say yes. However, providers of mobility options might be less enthusiastic to support this concept. Therefore, the answer is not a straight-forward yes. Nevertheless, firms which listen best to customers are the firms which generally survive. This might enhance the chances for success of MaaS!

References

Giesecke, R., Surakka, T., & Hakonen, M. (2016, April). Conceptualising mobility as a service. In 2016 Eleventh International Conference on Ecological Vehicles and Renewable Energies (EVER) (pp. 1-11). IEEE.

Gould, E., Wehrmeyer, W., & Leach, M. (2015). Transition pathways of e-mobility services. WIT Transactions on Ecology and The Environment, 194, 349–359.

https://www.rotterdam.nl/nieuws/lev_elektrische-deelauto/

König, D., Eckhardt, J., Aapaoja, A., Sochor, J. & Karlsson, M. (2016). Business and operator models for Mobility as a Service (MaaS) (Deliverable 3 to the MAASiFiE project). Brussels: Belgium.

Please rate this

Implementing 5G internet, should cities do it?

18

September

2019

5/5 (1)

Recently, the city of Amsterdam placed some critical notes on the installation of a 5G network in the city. Reasons for this critical attitude are the huge impact it has on the streetscape, concerns for health risks and the high costs involved with the installation of a 5G network (Telegraaf, 2019). Next to Amsterdam, Almere, Eindhoven and Rotterdam have also expressed their concerns about the implementation of a 5G network. The question which arises when hearing about these hesitations of cities related to 5G is: should cities actually implement a 5G network, or is it better to skip on this new development?

5G stands for the fifth generation of wireless networks and is expected to hit the markets in 2020. It will address the massive evolution towards a society in which Internet of Things plays a significant role. 5G will enable a very low latency, which is critical for real-time interactivity for services using the cloud. This is for example a key for success of Autonomous Vehicles (Gemalto, N.D).

Why would this be interesting for cities? Mainly, because of the many benefits 5G offers. Examples of these benefits are an increasing speed of internet, increasing reliability of internet, increased network coverage and lower battery consumptions (Dahiya, 2017). These benefits will be warmly welcomed by the citizens of a city. Besides, cities such as Amsterdam, Eindhoven, Rotterdam and Zwolle want to turn into Smart Cities. A smart city is a city that uses innovation and technology to improve quality of life, efficiency of urban operations and services In a Smart City, IoT plays a big role, and the implementation of 5G is an important success factor for IoT to function properly (Mohanty, Choppali & Kougianos, 2016).

It sounds like 5G offers quite some benefits for cities, right? However, why do cities then still have their doubts about it? Well, next to the concerns mentioned in the introduction, the implementation of a 5G network also requires the installation of many kilometers of glass-fibre networks, which will largely impact the infrastructure of a city (Telegraaf, 2019). Besides, as mentioned, 5G could have negative implications for your health. Researchers still don’t agree on how big the risks are of the radiation caused by 5G, but the fact that the risks are likely to exist, can be a reason for cities to not install a 5G network. Lastly, there is still some doubt about the integrity of the supplier of 5G, the Chinese company Huawei. The United States even blame Huawei being guilty of espionage (NOS, 2019).

So, should cities implement a 5G network? The answer to this question is not easy, mainly because the benefits of 5G are clear, while the concerns are not. Only the concerns about the costs, changing streetscape and the impact for the infrastructure are based on facts, while the other concerns might not be relevant. Therefore, I don’t give an answer to the question. Instead, I am curious to see what cities will do, and if by 2025 we all live in Smart Cities, not driving any car ourselves anymore, enabled by 5G.

References:

https://www.gemalto.com/brochures-site/download-site/Documents/tel-5G-networks-

QandA.pdf

Mohanty, S. P., Choppali, U., & Kougianos, E. (2016). Everything you wanted to know about

smart cities: The internet of things is the backbone. IEEE Consumer Electronics

Magazine5(3), 60-70.

https://nos.nl/nieuwsuur/artikel/2281716-5g-van-zelfrijdend-busje-tot-smart-potatoes-

maar-is-het-veilig-genoeg.html

https://www.telegraaf.nl/nieuws/562735827/amsterdam-kritisch-op-uitrol-5-g-internet

Please rate this